Skip to content
  • Members
  • .
  • About
    • Why Choose a Counselor?
    • Real Estate Counseling
    • The CRE Designation
    • Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • CRE Staff
    • Member Spotlight
  • Find a CRE
  • CRE Chapters
  • Media Resources
    • News Releases
    • Media Backgrounder
    • Member News
  • Contact Us
    • Mailing Address and Contact Information
    • CRE Staff
    • Privacy Policy
  • Cart

Counselors of Real Estate

The professional organization for the most trusted advisors in real estate

  • Membership
    • Why Be a Counselor?
    • Member Benefits
    • Qualifications
    • Ethics & Standards
    • Dues & Initiation Fees
    • Application & Application Process
    • Member News
    • Member Spotlight
  • Events
    • National & International Events
    • Chapter & Regional Events
    • Webinars & Virtual Events
    • Past Events
    • Recordings and Presentations
  • Initiatives
    • Disaster Response Resources
    • Consulting Corps
    • The CRE Foundation
    • CRE Specialty Interest Groups
    • Issues and Trends
    • Awards
  • Publications
    • CRE Library
    • The Counselor
    • Real Estate Issues
    • CRE Newsline
    • Podcast Episodes
    • Subscribe
Rotating Header Image
  • Members
    • Edit Profile
    • CRE Member Forum
    • Disaster Response Resources
    • CRE Meeting Presentations
    • 2020 CRE Committees
    • New Member Invitees/Reinstatements
    • Organization Documents
    • Recommend a New CRE
    • Submit News
    • 2020 Committee and Volunteer Opportunities
    • Past Chairs and Presidents
  • Membership
    • Why Be a Counselor?
    • Member Benefits
    • Qualifications
      • Qualities and Attributes of Successful Applicants
      • Eligibility
    • Ethics & Standards
    • Dues & Initiation Fees
    • Application & Application Process
    • Member News
    • Member Spotlight
  • Events
    • National & International Events
    • Chapter & Regional Events
    • Webinars & Virtual Events
    • Past Events
    • Recordings and Presentations
  • Initiatives
    • Disaster Response Resources
      • Disaster Response Discussion Board
      • Insights
    • Consulting Corps
      • Process & Fees
      • Project Summaries
      • Application for Services
      • Volunteering for the Consulting Corps
    • The CRE Foundation
      • Planned Giving
      • Application for Funding
      • Project Summaries
    • CRE Specialty Interest Groups
      • Upcoming Virtual Events
      • Specialty Interest Group Discussion Board
      • Register to Join CRE Specialty Interest Groups
      • Presentation Recordings
    • Issues and Trends
      • Top Ten Archive
    • Awards
  • Publications
    • CRE Library
    • The Counselor
    • Real Estate Issues
      • Real Estate Issues Archive
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Call for Submissions: Manuscripts on Impact of COVID-19 on Real Estate
    • CRE Newsline
      • Spring 2020
      • Winter 2020
      • Fall 2019
      • Summer 2019
      • Spring 2019
    • Podcast Episodes
    • Subscribe
  • .
  • About
    • Why Choose a Counselor?
    • Real Estate Counseling
    • The CRE Designation
    • Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • CRE Staff
    • Member Spotlight
  • Find a CRE
  • CRE Chapters
  • Media Resources
    • News Releases
    • Media Backgrounder
    • Member News
  • Contact Us
    • Mailing Address and Contact Information
    • CRE Staff
    • Privacy Policy
  • Cart
Members
  • Home
  • The Counselor
  • Summer 2018
  • Relative Value Remains in European Real Estate, Despite Record Low Cap Rates
  • Publications
    • CRE Library
    • The Counselor
    • Real Estate Issues
    • CRE Newsline
    • Podcast Episodes
    • Subscribe

Relative Value Remains in European Real Estate, Despite Record Low Cap Rates

By Dennis Schoenmaker, Ph.D.
Investment Research & Strategy | AEW Europe

and Hans J. Vrensen, CFA, CRE®
Head of Research & Strategy | AEW Europe

In the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis, unprecedented quantitative easing policies and record low policy rates created an abundance of liquidity or a “wall-of-money” into financial markets. Commercial real estate has not been an exception and has matured into a widely accepted financial asset type in the multi-asset investment portfolios of most national and international investors.

Over the last eight years, European investment volumes have recovered, then peaked in 2015. As a result, prime property yields or cap rates across five core European markets compressed from around 6.5% in 2009 to a record low of just above 4% in 2014 (see Figure 1). Because of this, investors are fully justified to question if there is still good value in European direct real estate. The simple answer to this is that real estate is expensive in absolute and historical terms. However, in an increasingly interconnected world where multi-asset investors become ever dominant, valuations are relative. Multi-asset investors do compare real estate to other asset classes to determine its relative value. Therefore, the more appropriate answer to the question has to involve comparing direct real estate with other asset classes, including stocks, bond and REITs. Only by following this approach can we really understand relative value.

Therefore, we implement a straightforward approach and introduce a so-called Z-score methodology to construct our European Relative Value index.1 This index is based on the equal weighted comparison of the following three variables: (1) prime property NOI multiple vs. corporate earnings multiples for stocks; (2) prime property yields vs government bond yields; and (3) premium or discount to NAV prices. Each is compared to its historical average through its Z-score, so as to take into account any historical bias from investors. Our methodology is similar to that adopted by our U.S. colleagues, as far as our data allowed.

When comparing the results of our index for Q4 2017 in more detail, UK prime property is slightly more fairly priced than markets such as France and Germany (see Figure 2). We could already see this from the divergence in yield movement since 2015 in Figure 1. Based on our index, the UK was less favourably priced before the Brexit-referendum, but this has reversed since then. The inverse was the case in France and Germany, as yields continued to tighten after the Brexit vote.

What does this mean for relative value going forward? Our index is not designed to really answer this, as we do not forecast REIT NAV discounts, government bond yields or stock earnings multiples. The answer is complicated as events that shape the future are not only difficult to predict, but are also interrelated — i.e., if bond yields widen, stock multiples could easily rise. However, when we do a yield normalization simulation under the assumption that everything else is equal, it does not change our results significantly as European real estate will still be fairly priced. Finally, when looking at the downsides we see less risk in the European markets compared to previous cycles, as new supply of space is more subdued and leverage has remained more modest on the back of stricter bank regulations. •

Endnotes

1. The approach, data selection, coverage and time-period is explained in AEW’s European Relative Direct Real Estate Index as published in March 2018: http://www.aeweurope.com/en/pdf/research/Q1-2018-AEW-Europe-Real-Estate-Quarterly-EN.pdf ↩


Dennis Schoenmaker, Ph.D., is a specialist in real estate economics. He joined AEW in 2017 as an associate in the Research & Strategy team, focusing on the pan-European commercial real estate market.

Hans Vrensen, CFA, CRE®, is an AEW managing director heading the European Research & Strategy team. He is a seasoned analyst in the international commercial real estate and capital markets with over 25 years of experience.

  • Membership
    • Why Be a Counselor?
    • Member Benefits
    • Qualifications
    • Ethics & Standards
    • Dues & Initiation Fees
    • Application & Application Process
    • Member News
    • Member Spotlight
  • Events
    • National & International Events
    • Chapter & Regional Events
    • Webinars & Virtual Events
    • Past Events
    • Recordings and Presentations
  • Initiatives
    • Disaster Response Resources
    • Consulting Corps
    • The CRE Foundation
    • CRE Specialty Interest Groups
    • Issues and Trends
    • Awards
  • Publications
    • CRE Library
    • The Counselor
    • Real Estate Issues
    • CRE Newsline
    • Podcast Episodes
    • Subscribe

Counselors of Real Estate

The professional organization for the most trusted advisors in real estate

The professional organization for the most trusted advisors in real estate.

© 2021 The Counselors of Real Estate
  • .
  • About
  • Find a CRE
  • CRE Chapters
  • Media Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Cart

Your Privacy

CRE.org uses cookies to enhance your website experience. By continuing to browse the site, you consent to our use of cookies. To learn more, please refer to our Privacy Policy.